1. Current Location: Home >  Router Encyclopedia >  A mobile phone appears twice in the background of the router? It’s not about using the internet, it’s about these three sources

A mobile phone appears twice in the background of the router? It’s not about using the internet, it’s about these three sources

There are three reasons why a mobile phone appears twice in the router's background device list.: Dual-frequency dual-recording, random MAC vest replacement, Mesh node residue, and the impact and management of leaky pipes blocked by speed limits.

When I was helping Lao Sun clear the equipment, I developed a habit of clicking on the device list in the background of the router and counting them every once in a while. Something strange happened last month: The list clearly stated that 53 stations were online. I clicked on the names one by one and counted 62 records. There is no more than one, and the nine extra ones are all things that are already at home - the wife’s iPhone appears twice, the sweeper appears twice, and even the camera at the door appears twice.

My first reaction was that someone had taken advantage of the Internet and copied a MAC. I almost disabled all the "extra" records, but luckily I clicked on the details page of the record first.: The name, signal, and online time are almost exactly the same as the "original station". After looking through the information for a long time and trying it on two routers, I figured out where these nine duplicate records came from. If we don’t understand this matter clearly, the device-based functions such as speed limit, blacklisting, and parental control may only control half of them.

First put the three sources on the table and take your seats facing the numbers.

A mobile phone appears twice in the list and has three origins. It looks very similar but has completely different roots. There are 9 duplicates in my house, and all three routes are taken.

origin what does it look like What is fundamentally
Dual frequency dual recording The same device, one each for 2.4G and 5G When the mobile phone is connected to 2.4G, it occupies one channel. Move to a place with good 5G signal and switch to it. It will take a few minutes to a few hours for the old records to age out.
Random MAC for vest Same device, two different MACs The mobile phone system generates a "private address" for each WiFi name, one address for the main network, and another for the IoT network.
Mesh node residue The same device has one entry under multiple node names. The mobile phone roams from the living room node to the bedroom node. The record of the old node has not reached the aging time and temporarily coexists.

The three origins have one thing in common: The router's device list is not a "household book" but a "registry book". It only remembers "who knocked on the door recently and which door they entered through." The record needs to be cleared slowly over time, and no one will take the initiative to remove duplicates. Therefore, the number of entries in the list is greater than the actual number of devices. This is a normal phenomenon and does not mean that the router is broken.

first way: Each dual frequency band occupies one channel, which is most obvious when changing frequency bands.

Dual-band is the most common and easiest to see through. If your home WiFi has two separate names, 2.4G and 5G, and the mobile phone is connected to different frequency bands, they will be two independent records. The trouble lies in the dual-band-in-one setup: The names are combined into one, and the mobile phone selects the frequency band by itself. You think it has only one record, but in fact there is one record for 2.4G and 5G in the background.

I tried it on Mercury D191G: Before I turned off dual-band integration, my wife’s phone was only one item in the list. ; After turning it off and re-separating, she connected to 5G in the living room. The 5G record in the list was on, and there was a gray 2.4G record lying next to it - she had connected it in the bedroom the day before yesterday, and it had not aged. After waiting for a long time, the one disappeared by itself.

The real pitfalls of dual-band and dual-recording are speed limits and blacklisting. Limit the speed of the "TV box" to 50 MB. What you click is the 2.4G record it is currently connected to. ; When the box is moved to the 5G channel, the speed limit rules follow the MAC, but the frequency band changes and the records change. Some backgrounds operate according to "device + frequency band", and there is an illusion that the speed limit suddenly fails. I stepped into this trap in the Mercury speed limit article. Dual frequency two records It was the first of the three major causes of failure at that time. Tengda has a bad temper backstage, Wrong unit for speed limit That article also mentioned the same thing. The blacklist is the hardest hit area. I blocked the 2.4G one, but I can still get in through the 5G one. Block three levels I call this "only half the door blocked."

second way: Random MAC, two identities for one phone

The second route is deeper. Starting from a certain system version, mobile phones will generate a private MAC address for each WiFi network by default - one address for your home main network, another address for your home IoT private network, and a third address for the company WiFi. It's still the same mobile phone. In the background, it looks like two unrelated devices, and the manufacturer can't find out.

Of the 9 extra ones in my house, 3 have this origin.: The corridor camera was connected to the main network once during the network configuration two years ago. Later I moved it to the IoT private network. The old main network record was not clear at all and it was always grayed out in the list. ; The same goes for sweepers and thermometers and hygrometers. The principles and details are here The random MAC article I have drawn a picture here, and here is an account from a list perspective.: The most confusing thing about this kind of duplication is that the two MACs are completely different. One OUI manufacturer can find out Xiaomi and the other cannot, especially like Cengwang.

I always use one trick to distinguish them.: Click on the details page of the two records to compare the "first connection time". The duplicates generated by random MACs, the first connection times of the two are far different (one was two years ago, and the other was the day the network was moved last week), and the signal strength is also calculated according to their respective access points. For unfamiliar devices that really use the Internet, the first connection time is usually very recent, and the signal is pretty good - this idea of ​​identifying people is similar to The article about catching netizens The three-field pair table is the same, except that "the thief who changed the MAC" was replaced by "the person who changed the vest".

The third way: Mesh multi-node, the tail left by mobile phone roaming

Families that have formed a mesh will have an extra layer. The "connected devices" of the router are actually summarized from each node.: When the mobile phone is in the living room, it is registered under the name of the living room node. When it goes to the bedroom, roaming switches, a new node is added in the bedroom, and the one in the living room has to wait for aging. Therefore, the more frequent the roaming family, the more instantaneous repetitions in the list, which can be digested in a few to ten minutes.

To see through this layer, you have to understand the concept of BSSID - behind the same WiFi name are several physical machines, each with its own number. The mobile phone shows that it is connected to "my home WiFi", but it is actually connected to a node with a specific number. I'm here There are several machines hidden behind the WiFi name It was specifically dismantled in that article. The BSSID column can be directly seen on some device details pages in the backend. The BSSIDs of the two records are different, so they are each hung on a node. Just wait and do not need to do anything.

This approach is basically harmless, the only disturbance is psychological.: Looking at the list of 62 and 55 items, I thought that the equipment in my home was increasing and decreasing out of thin air. After knowing that it was the roaming tail, this fluctuation became a signal confirming that the roaming was working normally.

There are three practical effects of duplicate recording, each of which must be taken into account

It seems that it is just a display problem, but there are actually three impacts. All of them are that the function of "operating by device" is compromised by repeated recording.

Affected features what happened what to do
speed limit The rules only stick to the record at that time and will become invalid after changing the frequency band and vest. For dual-band machines, set both 2.4G and 5G, or reset them after naming them uniformly.
Blocking/Parental Control Pull one and the other one shines in, the child changes the frequency band and goes around it. Dispose of both records before blocking them and confirm that there are no remaining records in the list.
Machine volume statistics The count is falsely high, the actual number of 53 units was reported as 62 units Just be aware of it, Nominal 128 units Families generally cannot reach the upper limit

Please say one more thing about this when taking the machine to measure it. The 62 records in my house at that time shocked me. I actually checked it out and found that there were actually 53 of them, and several of them were small sensors with one watt of standby power. The account with machine quantity is here 62 devices greatly reduced the size I calculated in that article that the number of inflated records that were repeatedly recorded is far from the router's processing limit, so there is no need to clear the list specifically for this.

However, speed limits and blacklists can really leak. Lao Sun's family limited the speed of his child's tablet. Two days later, he complained to me that the speed limit made him feel lonely. I looked through his background and found two records on the tablet. The one set by the rules was the old one, and the child had already switched to another frequency band. This situation is not because the speed limit function is not working, but because it faithfully manages a record that is no longer working.

Governance Three Axes: Change name, turn off random MAC, regular reconciliation

Once you know the origin, governance is the easiest part of the entire process. My current method is three steps, and it takes about ten minutes to complete.

The first step is to change the remark name of the device. If the background supports editing of device names, change the default name of "Xiaomi-Redmi-XXXX" to "Living Room-Sweeping Machine", change both dual-frequency devices, and then reconcile the names after changing the names. You will know which ones are the same device at a glance. The second problem is that long-term devices at home turn off random MACs - there is a "private address" switch in the mobile phone WiFi details. After turning it off, it uses its own real MAC, and the main network IoT network connects back and forth with the same identity, and the list is immediately reduced by half. Which types of devices should be turned off and which should be kept as default? The article about mobile phone being disconnected divided into stages according to scenes: It is uneconomical to turn off anti-tracking on smart devices. Your mobile phone depends on your functional needs.

The third step is to reconcile the accounts every one or two months.: Count through the list, click out the gray old records (some backgrounds support manual deletion, and those that do not support it will wait for it to age naturally), and then take out the unfamiliar entries with particularly new first connection times and go through the three-field table. This set of reconciliation steps will take five minutes. After doing this, you will have a more accurate estimate of "how many devices are connected to the Internet" in your home than the router.

Finally give it all: The essence of the phenomenon of repeated recording is that the router's registration mechanism truly reflects the fact that "one device has multiple identities." It is not considered a defect if it is not broken. What you really need to be wary of is never the length of the list, but the items in the list whose first connection time is very recent, the signal is good, and the names cannot be called out - that is another matter, and you have to follow the process of surfing the Internet. Only by distinguishing between the two can the list in the background be really understood.

Read More


Copyright Notice Scan to read on mobile
All Rights Reserved: 《SHUNOT》 => 《A mobile phone appears twice in the background of the router? It’s not about using the internet, it’s about these three sources 》
Article URL: https://www.shunot.com/en/lybk/1566.html
Unless otherwise stated, all articles are original by 《SHUNOT》. Reposting is welcome! Please indicate the original URL when reposting, thank you.

Contact Us

Online Consultation: Click here to send me a message

WeChat ID: master_135

Scan to follow