Feiniu NAS Benchmarks Synology: SHR and Whole-Device Backup Half Can Be Substitutes

After I switched my main machine at home to Feiniu last year, the most awkward month for me was right after I switched to it. Searching "how to open NAS snapshots" only yields screenshots from DSM; Searching for 'How to build arrays on two different disks'—nine out of ten suggest using SHR, but I searched Feiniu's storage settings three times and couldn't find these three letters. The menu didn't match, and at one point I wondered if I had installed a low-health version.
Later, I managed both the Feiniu at home and my mom's old Synology DS220J together for over half a year, and finally settled the score: some of Synology's signature features were native to Feiniu, some were renamed after a new name, and the only real missing feature was two. There are ways to bypass the two missing items, but it requires a bit more effort. Let's go through the check-ins one by one.
First, let's talk about things you can copy directly: snapshots, albums, etc.—Feiniu has them themselves
.Let me correct my biggest misunderstanding at the time: not that all Synology tutorials can't be used, but that the menu names don't match. Synology has a suite called Snapshot Replication, which timers to take snapshots of shared folders, and if accidentally deleted, they roll back. Feiniu still has this feature, provided there's only one thing—the day you set up the storage space, you chose Btrfs. At that time, I used two drives: one Btrfs and one ext4. The Btrfs drive could take snapshots, but the ext4 drive had no option and I thought the system was broken. I have carefully calculated this selection plan in the ext4 and Btrfs articles: to take snapshots, you have to pick the right one on the day the banner is built, and there's no regret in making changes after slotting.
I've seen snapshots with my own eyes how life-saving they are. My husband deleted six months' worth of phone photos as duplicate catalogs in one go, and that night they even cleared the recycle bin. In the end, they managed to retrieve the hourly snapshots exactly as they were. It took less than ten minutes, accidentally deleted the entire rescue post. On Synology's side, snapshots can be set to take every five minutes and copy to another device. Feiniu's snapshot management interface is simpler, so you have to set it up yourself to keep the strategy, but at home, this level is more than enough.
The photo album is the same. Synology's Synology Photos appears frequently in tutorials. Feiniu's app corresponds to the built-in photo gallery app. After installing the app on your phone and checking auto backup, over 40,000 photos and over 300GB are stored on the NAS, and facial recognition can be enabled. It took a day and a half to build the index for 40,000 photos. I < all of this > a href="https://www.shunot.com/en/nas/963.html" and < href="https://www.shunot.com/en/nas/865.html" >Facial recognition has been tested in two articles. So the first conclusion is: for everyday features like snapshots, albums, movies, and Docker, Feiniu doesn't owe much. Just copy the ideas from the tutorials—just recognize the functions, not the menu names.
SHR really doesn't exist: mix capacity drives to calculate this before acting
.Next is the first thing that really lacks. SHR is proprietary to Synology; Feiniu's system doesn't even have this option. This isn't a version issue—it's that they simply don't open source. It addresses very specific scenarios: two drives with different capacities, like 4TB versus 8TB, SHR will automatically tier them, and the available space can reach 8TB. I calculated this step by step in comparing SHR and RAID1.
On Feiniu's side, the same two plates only have two paths. First, set up a standard RAID 1, cut the smaller available space, leaving only 4TB, half the 8TB drive wasting idle capacity. Second, use both disks separately—4T plus 8T, totaling 12T—but no redundancy at all—lose every piece you use. My choice at the time was divide and conquer: for photo drives that were a huge loss, I obediently RAID1 with two drives of the same capacity; If a download disk breaks, you can reinstall it. Run a single drive and use backup strategies as a backup. This divide-and-conquer strategy by disk was written in the article how to choose RAID, and it has nothing to do with whether SHR is available.
So SHR's real conclusion in this round is: already on Feiniu and holding mixed capacity drives, they have to choose one or the other and accept the loss; For those who haven't bought yet, it's actually simple—just buy two units of the same capacity, and you won't get the loss from SHR from the start. The cost is that on the day of the purchase, you can't just pick up cheap scraps.
The biggest loophole is the whole system backup: you have to patch it up yourself on the computer
side.The second thing really lacking is Active Backup for Business, which is Synology's full system backup. It can back up the entire family computer to the NAS at the block level, and if the system crashes, plug in a USB drive for half an hour to restore the whole device. It's free and unlimited on the number of devices. I used three computers in the article about restoring the storage plan after redoing it. Feiniu has no equip, which I believe is the only major flaw since switching the system.
But breaking down the demand, it's not desperate. Most people don't want a "whole mirror," but "don't throw away files." Feiniu can handle the file layer: Mac Time Machine has been natively supported since version 0.8.27. Just check the control panel and it can serve as a target for Time Machine. Remember to set the quota strictly—I didn't set it on my first trip, it quietly consumes over 700GB. On Windows, you just use the built-in file history and point to the NAS network location. By default, only backups are made up of libraries and desktops, and you have to add the D drive yourself. I < the full process of a href="https://www.shunot.com/en/nas/935.html" > computer backup version. When the system crashes and you reinstall and drag files back, it's a hassle but not a single hair of data is missing.
If you really need a full disk of image software, such as a pre-configured development environment on your computer, install a whole disk of image software and store the image files in the NAS shared directory, so the NAS obediently acts as a storage disk. Speaking of price differences, it's that the restoration step takes a few hours longer than Synology's bare-phone restoration, and I accept that cost.
No need to worry about sync disks: Feiniu Sync has three one-to-one modes, Syncthing even makes free remote
profits. Synology Drive is another high-frequency term in the tutorial: two-way sync, upload-only, and download-only. Accidental deletion can lead to sync-up infection. I've fallen into the trap of DriveI wrote about it in particular. This Feiniu alternative is the easiest for me: the official version has 'Feiniu Sync.' Both Windows and Mac have clients, and you can create tasks by connecting to your NAS and authorizing them. The three modes are almost one-to-one—bidirectional sync mirrors both ends, only uploading means the computer deletes the NAS but keeps it, and only downloading reverses. I was too lazy to even change the name, just follow Synology's tutorial and use it directly.
My setup is to set the work directory to only upload, cutting off the path of accidental deletion and infection at the root. The cost is that the NAS occasionally accumulates a few ####开头的冲突文件, and I manually clean up whenever I see it. To be fair, Feiniu Sync is more straightforward than Drive. For example, the filtering rules only go up to the "exclude by size and format" layer. The system drive and OneDrive directory will remind you not to select them, but advanced features like version rollback are absent.
Even more appealing is another: Syncthing. Since the end of October 2024, Feiniu has been installing it in the App Center, allowing it to be installed with one click in the backup sync category, without needing to touch Docker commands. It is P2P direct connection; after two devices are added, even if one is home and the other is at the office, different local networks can automatically synchronize without any internal network penetration. This point, in turn, puts Synology in the spotlight—if Drive wants to sync across networks, it still needs to leverage the QuickConnect relay channel. So in this synchronized match, Feiniu not only didn't lose, but actually profited a bit.
Hyper Backup work: rsync and rclone relay
Synology also has Hyper Backup, which handles incremental and deduplication backups, pushing data to another machine or the cloud. Feiniu doesn't have this kit, but I pieced it together in three sections. First paragraph: Remote location: Using rsync to run SSH scheduling between two NAS. My Feiniu is the source terminal, and my mom's old Synology is used as a target device, running automatically at 3:30 a.m. The photo library of over 200GB was completed over two nights. How to set up permission pitfalls and scheduled tasks for password-free login? There are ready-made commands you can copy from the remote backup post.
Section Two, Cloud: Using rclone to push the most critical items onto NutCloud's WebDAV—work documents, scanned IDs, password database, home records, totaling over 600MB. The free version of NutCloud only uploads 1GB of data per month. Don't even think about stuffing the entire photo library into it. At that limit, you can transfer for over ten years, and only small files that could cause big problems if lost are just right. NutCloud even explains how to generate app passwords. Section three, cold backup: a retired 4TB drive, synchronized every six months, SHA256 checklist reconciliation and stuffed back into the anti-static bag in the drawer, details of cold backup also separately recorded.
The three segments together essentially form the 3-2-1 rule: local redundancy, one remote one, and one offline one. Synology handled everything with just one kit, while Feiniu had to assemble three tools by themselves, which took twice as much effort, but holding each layer in their own hands actually gave them peace of mind.
Remote access is worth flying bull in this round. Let's pull out the main account and
finally talk about remote access. Synology's QuickConnect is well-known, but its relay channel shares bandwidth, and in practice, it's only a few megabytes per second. During peak times, it's all about luck. I've discussed the principle of slow speed and the way to speed up in my article QuickConnect. Feiniu's FN remote direct connection means no public IP needed, so you can connect home directly when out and about, with speeds running right up your home broadband. In this game, Feiniu not only didn't lose but also played smoothly.
Summarizing the results of more than half a year into a single table:
| Synology | SignatureFeiniu | |
|---|---|---|
| Snapshot Replication | Btrfs Snapshot—if you set up a matching pool, you can | find an alternative |
| Synology Photos albums | Feiniu Photo Album + mobile app | can replace |
| Synology Drive Sync, | Feiniu Sync / Syncthing | can be an alternative and also profits |
| QuickConnect Remote | FN Remote Direct | Connection Feiniu has the advantage |
| SHR mixed-capacity array | standard RAID or single-drive + backup | really doesn't exist; switch to |
| system backup is really not available on ABB. | TimeMachine/File History/Image Software | really doesn't have it. Assemble and add |
| Hyper Backup | rsync+ rclone + Cold Standby | DriveThree-Piece Bundle |
Who Should Endure Using Feiniu: For those with a tight budget, the drive already has the same capacity, and the main need is daily functions like photo and video downloads—the first four rows in the table above are enough for you, and the two missing items can be made up for with a bit more effort. Who should go straight to Synology: those with drives of different capacities for peace of mind, those who want to back up three to five computers in their family for a full backup, or those who don't want to bother with the suite ecosystem. How to choose between these two groups? In the article comparing Synology and Feiniu, there is a more comprehensive six-dimensional table. My answer is that I keep both, but if you ask which one I actually entrust the data to, it's my own Feiniu—every layer of backup is connected by me wire-by-wire. I know exactly what goes wrong, how to fix it, and I know exactly what happens.
